Please Note: Comment Approval is normally undertaken twice a day as time & circumstances permit.
Please check out yesternoir.org: HERE.
Please check out yesternoir.org: HERE.
There have been numerous books written about pirate or free radio if you prefer. Radio Caroline has been the subject or setting for a few. Having read many of these publications, the personal accounts by the likes of Steve Conway have for me been the most interesting and often quite entertaining. Books like Pop Went The Pirates by Keith Skues are reasonable records of a now bygone era, and Gerry Bishop's Offshore Radio book was a real attempt to make a record of each station without any bells or whistles attached. All may contain inaccuracies, some more so than others, in fact it seems that where money is the motive rather than historical research, the attention to detail versus the hurry to cash in, has had a negative impact. Which raises the question, what do readers actually want? Is it a nostalgia trip with all your perceived favourite moments recounted, a detailed and thoroughly researched reexamination of events with new sources providing details previously not known or only known by a few. Or perhaps you might like a candid warts and all account of what life really was like, including the good and bad moments. Maybe you just want pictures of the ships and DJ's hopefully ones you have not seen before. What seems to be increasingly clear is the latest book to arrive (The Caroline Bible) is as much about the money and the author makes that clear. He states the need to be out for the Xmas market to get a return on the investment, in fact this seems vital. Add to this the rallying call to all anoraks that his book is best and another book project not yet published is going to be an unfair hatchet job because... well because he say's so, and I sense a plea to please buy the book. Some early fact checking throws up the hilarious lack of research as to whom wrote The O'Rahilly (WB Yeats would not be pleased). However the author tells us that "The book is incomplete, but one must draw the line on the level of detail." Indeed and the level of accuracy one wonders. That Paul Rusling felt the need to come out all guns blazing against Mervyn Hagger and defend rather than research again the period around 1962 to 1964 himself (but Oonagh told me, so it has to be right), seems to seal the inference that this is about unloading some cash from the ever diminishing and seemingly brainwashed anoraks that cannot allow anyone to challenge their perception of reality, especially if one of their church leaders comes under the spotlight. Personally I like accuracy and detail, with verifiable sources and a level of peer review and proof reading usually helps. So if you want to read some quality material I recommend SK Moore's 'Life And Death Of A Pirate', available on Amazon, and refreshingly accurate. Or why not head over to the Freewave magazine website and read Andy Archers 'Arseholes and Anoraks' LINK: http://freewave-media-magazine.nl/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/Freewave-451-452.pdf For those fanatical Caroline fans, read the full account and see how many people were taken advantage of by a poor ill old man (cue violins Freddie) who these days can't defend himself.
13 Comments
Ed Abovewater
12/11/2019 07:09:10 pm
I do not think it unreasonable for an author to publish a book, promote it and expect to make a profit from it. Is that not the point in most cases? Look at those who do the rounds of TV programmes and book signings in order to do just that. The purchasers or prospective purchasers must decide for themselves whether the item is a sensible purchase or not. As sales progress and reviews emerge, then there is an addition aid to help the punters decide. For the book in question it has been condemned by a few based purely on a couple of inaccuracies, and not on the whole. Neither have critics said what they consider to be accurate within the book. My personal view is that the author has had to mount some sort of defence against those who have made only negative comments which smack of sour grapes and resentment at being caught on the hop. Let the primary critic write a balanced and honest review, and publish his own much trumpeted volume(s). Enthusiasts may buy both, particularly collectors. The masses will probably go for whatever has received the most publicity, has been marketed effectively, looks good on the coffee table or is the most readable. Time spent bleating about rival publications is time that could be better spent concentrating on the job in hand.
Reply
ADMIN
12/11/2019 07:31:12 pm
On this occasion it was however Paul R lobbing the verbal grenades on Garry's forum, was there any need to even mention Mr Hagger? And sorry but Yeats versus Keats is an issue because something as important and easily checked as that is just plain sloppy & a little insulting to Ronan's family. I have no issue with people making money out of books, and if they are happy to settle for this type of standard that's up to them. The four pages shared at least give potential purchasers an idea of what to expect, for me personally they are enough to make it a No No.
Reply
Ed Abovewater
12/11/2019 07:53:01 pm
I would prefer to have an unbiased but knowledgeable appraisal by someone who has read the whole book, which cannot be judged by it's cover or by four pages. Equally, if you watch the 'Dial 999 for Caroline' (Part One) video you might conclude that it is poorly produced and very amateurish, and therefore anything else from the same stable should be dismissed. There are always errors, omissions, production or publishing issues of one sort or another. In this instance opinions are also influenced by the past behaviour of the main protaganists.
Reply
Mervyn Hagger
12/11/2019 08:10:33 pm
Excuse me for butting in Ed, but you who are hiding behind a silly last name - Ed - are drowning in a pool of sweat. You must be, because there is no such video as the one you describe. There is a video called 'Yesterday Never Happened' which was made months ago before we made major discoveries about the origins of Radio Caroline. But what you will learn from that video is that Ronan O'Rahilly lied constantly and consistently to fool people like you and to enable others to fleece you into buying a ridiculous story. Now with regards to the 4 pages mentioned by Mike, why is it that the author of the 'Bible' sent me in advance, 4 pages with more-or-less the same pagination - but with a totally different story-line? It seems that the change was made after I strongly objected to being listed as a contributor. I was not and my name was removed from the list. But so was a big chunk of the text. I am not aiming at the anorak market but the true crime market, because the story of Radio Caroline from 1964-1967 is one of international crime including the Mafia and murder. The delay in releasing more information is due to the heavy research that has been undertaken and I guarantee that the resulting book will shock the anorak community and provide the international book-buying commuters a gripping page-turner that they won't want to put down while constantly wondering why hasn't this story been told before?
Reply
Ed Abovewater
12/11/2019 08:23:15 pm
My mistake, but, the video has 'Dial 999 for Caroline' emblazened all over it! You see, here you go again. No reasoned response, just trotting out the same old piffle, not addressing the points raise, no sense of reason and a raft of insults. You just never learn, do you, and you are incapable of conducting a sensible discussion.
Reply
Mervyn Hagger
12/11/2019 08:34:33 pm
Ed, like all brainwashed trolls you make accusations without foundation. The video begins with a set piece called 'Yesterday Never Happened' and it ends with that name. There is a segment in which a phone is dialed with the name 'Dial 999 for Caroline' which ends with Ronan O'Rahilly picking up his GPO phone. There is also a big sequence involving KILT, Houston and Galveston, but you chose to ignore all of that to make your crude point. But let me ask you a question Ed. Why do I have 4 pages from the 'Bible' that differ from the 4 pages that have been offered on the Garry Stevens' Forum - after I demanded that my name be removed from the list of contributors to that book? It makes me wonder if your first name really begins with the letter 'P''?
Reply
Ed Abovewater
12/11/2019 08:49:03 pm
Well, you chose to ignore my points, instead deciding to attack because of a misnomer. At least Admin's response made sense. No, Mervyn I do not know why blah, blah, blah, neither do I care. Why don't you ask someone who has the answer? My first name does not begin with 'P' either, whatever you may be trying to infer. Sort yourself out, for goodness sake. I could retaliate in a like manner, but refuse to stoop to your tawdry level.
Reply
Mervyn Hagger
12/11/2019 09:05:52 pm
Yes, Ed, I can see why you and other trolls hide behind silly names due to your transparent dishonesty. That is why I wanted nothing to do with your 'bible'.
Reply
Ed Abovewater
12/11/2019 09:37:20 pm
It is not my bible. It is a book which is on my Christmas list, to be read along with others, to be critiqued when I have read it. I do not dismiss it out of hand. I will do likewise with yours, should it ever see the light of day.
Reply
Mervyn Hagger
12/11/2019 09:55:40 pm
Please don't buy the book I am working on because you are obviously unhinged and this could send you over the cliff. You wrote "blah, blah, blah" like a child when I asked you why the 4 pages you have seen are different to the 4 pages sent to me. The fact is that your bible is a distorted version of reality, and unvarnished reality could make your dream world collapse around you with unforeseen consequences. Don't buy 'Dial 999 for Caroline' because you cannot handle the true story.
Reply
Testing 1.2,3
12/11/2019 10:11:09 pm
Blimey Merv ,calm down or you'll burst a blood vessel which won't be good at your time of life.
Reply
Ed Abovewater
12/11/2019 10:39:04 pm
Good advice, which I fear will go unheeded. I will not post here again as a healthy and frank discussion will get hijacked (again) and end like this (again).
Reply
The Nutter on the bus
15/11/2019 03:10:58 am
Stick with it. There are a lot of parallels!
Reply
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
Radio Now & Then
Each article can receive your replies (comments). We will not tolerate bad language, trolls, or unprovoked personal attacks. Unlike other places however you are allowed to express your personal opinions however much they may differ with the original article, as long as they are constructive. Categories |